Nora and Trey* were married for sixteen years when she discovered Trey’s infidelity. “It was like a grenade hurled into my life,” she said. “His affair partner showed up at the house.” She hid her face in her hands while recalling the memory. “She wanted to get back at him for breaking up with her, for choosing me. I felt anything but lucky just then.”
After the initial shock eased (which took more than three months), Nora decided to work with her husband to attempt to heal the marriage. “Trey and I both experienced the pain of parents splitting when we were kids. So for our children’s sake, I wanted to at least try and see if we could stay together.”
What she said she didn’t expect when looking ahead at the long road of infidelity recovery was being gaslit by Trey. “Beyond having an affair and lying to me for nearly a year to make it happen, I didn’t think he could mess with my mind any further. But I was wrong. I didn’t see the gaslighting I’d been enduring or the gaslighting on the horizon, and most times, didn’t even recognize it as such while he was gaslighting me.” She covered her face again. “I made it about myself, like I was the one with the problem. And he allowed that, caused it. If that’s not emotional abuse, I don’t know what is.”
It’s important to keep in mind that not all deception or denial during an affair constitutes gaslighting. Specifically, gaslighting involves a pattern of deliberately undermining another person’s belief in the validity of their own perceptions and judgment.
Today’s article will explore the experience of being on the receiving end of gaslighting, from Nora’s perspective.
__________
Nora’s story
The emergence of gaslighting: At first, it was subtle. . .
I knew something was wrong, something was off. Something between us. He felt distant to me, preoccupied. Distracted in a way I hadn’t felt before, even when he’d been under stress at work, even after his mom died. This was like he was trying to pretend to be present for me and the kids (when he wasn’t working late, which he had been doing a lot at the time), but even as he sat there—absently eating popcorn or petting the dog or listening to one of the kids’ stories—he wasn’t really there. And to me, it felt like the strain of the pretense was tiring him. It was as if he was wearing a mask of falsity, but it didn’t fit quite right.
And his affection toward me was waning. He seemed just as affectionate as ever with the kids, but not with me. He’d been going to bed early, skipping our TV hour on the sofa together under a blanket, shoulder to shoulder. Already asleep when I was done with kitchen clean-up and kids’ lunches and came to bed. . .or else he pretended to be.
Finally I confronted him about it, but Trey said he’d been noticing the same thing about me —“a distance in you, Nora. . .you’re keeping me at arm’s length”—and so anything I thought I was observing in him was actually projection. My own projection. “You know what they say,” he said (smugly) one night before turning off his bedside light and unilaterally ending the discussion. “You can’t see a trait in someone else unless you yourself possess that trait.”
Oof, I wanted to scream. And yet. And yet, with him sleeping beside me, his words played and replayed in my head, and I wondered if there was some truth to them. After all, I had been under stress at work. One of our daughters was going through a tough time at school, and maybe that was weighing on me more than I realized. My sister had recently been diagnosed with breast cancer, and though her prognosis was good, naturally I was worried. Maybe that was making me the distant one in the marriage? Maybe I was trying too hard to appear present for my family?
What if I was just imagining things in him to provide a distraction away from my own stressors?
The next morning he was up earlier than usual, and he nearly left for work without saying goodbye. Again, not typical. I walked into the kitchen as he was picking up his briefcase. In response to my quizzical expression over what appeared to be his sneaking out, he said, “I didn’t want to wake you. You need your sleep. I have to head in early to prep for the big presentation.”
“Are you trying to avoid me?” I asked.
“Nore, what are you saying?” He scowled, raked his fingers through his hair as he looked away. “Last night I told you I had to head out super early today.”
“You didn’t say any such thing to me.” I was certain.
“Nora, once you worked through your past insecurities, that long history of all that you struggled with before we even met, I thought we had a rocksolid level of trust between us.” He gazed through the window into the backyard. “Everyone I know is jealous of how much we trust each other. Don’t tell me that’s crumbling in you?”
I felt sheepish. Like I should apologize. Many years ago I had told him about my insecurity in early romantic relationships, how I often felt unworthy of love, how it was hard for me to believe a dynamic person would choose me as “the one,” how I would sometimes interrogate them about their choice so relentlessly that it would cause them to turn away. But that was before I met Trey. I had done the work in therapy for that; that wasn’t at the root of what I was sensing between us now. At least I didn’t think it was.
He strode over to me, curtly kissed me on my temple, and ducked out before he noticed my arms opening for a hug.
It was only after his car exited the garage that I realized this was the first I’d heard about a big presentation.
Suddenly, I felt a little woozy. Too queasy to care about breakfast.
At work later that day, a coworker came to me with an error I had made on a report. A newbie mistake, a simple thing I overlooked, but with significant implications if it hadn’t been caught. And that brought me back to my discussion with Trey. What if he had told me about a big presentation, and I’d forgotten? What if he had indeed mentioned his atypical schedule for today and I didn’t hold onto it?
And more importantly, what if my suspicious questioning was adding a layer of mistrust onto a good relationship? What if my scatteredness could drive him away?
“You can’t accuse me without proof. . .”
In the weeks that followed, there were other instances that sank me further into waves of disorienting uneasiness, but nothing that screamed INFIDELITY! like lipstick on his collar or a motel charge on our credit card would.
He was late to our daughter’s school play. So late that he missed her speaking part entirely. “There was a wreck on I91,” he whispered to me while I stared straight ahead at the stage. “I texted to let you know but I get why you weren’t looking at your phone.” And then a little later, upbeat. “So how’d our girl do? And when do we get the recording?”
While I was brushing my teeth one night and he was already in bed, I heard him chuckling softly. When I walked into the room, he speedily clicked off his phone screen and dropped it into his nightstand drawer, a place I never saw him stow it.
“What’s up with that?” I asked.
“With what?”
“Since when do you keep your phone out of sight?”
“I’m practicing good sleep hygiene,” he said. “I read an article about it. Gotta start somewhere.”
“And what were you laughing at?”
“What’s that?” he asked.
“When I came in, you were laughing.”
“Oh!” he said, with more gusto than the moment called for. “Jimmy from work, just being the ham he always is. You know Jimmy!”
(I didn’t know Jimmy.)
I’d been hoping we could be intimate that night—it had been awhile—but the moment devolved into me pressing him about what exactly Jimmy had said, and him feeling affronted by “getting trapped in an interrogation room over a laugh with a buddy,” and he turned on his side away from me, punched his pillow, and turned out his light.
That night had just been starting to fade from the busy part of my brain when I ran into a friend of Trey’s at the grocery store. Keith and Trey had been college roommates and close ever since, and we periodically went to dinner with he and his partner.
“Haven’t seen you in ages!” he exclaimed, wrapping me in a hug. “How you been?”
“We have to get something on the calendar for the four of us,” I said, genuinely looking forward to it. “I’ll check with my sister, see if she can watch the kids soon.”
“And how’s that dude you married? Too busy climbing the corporate ladder for trivia night with his old friend, huh?”
A faint high-pitched whirr kicked up in my ears and pushed me off-kilter. Even though I was still standing in the produce aisle with misters hissing on and off around me, inside I was being tossed around a choppy ocean in a leaky boat.
“B-b-but he was there last m-m-month,” I managed.
Keith shook his head. “I wish! I’d assembled a cracker-jack team, we could’ve finally won if we had Trey.” And then he seemed to read my confusion, identify my seasickness. His face fell and he mumbled something about thinking of the wrong month maybe and I should give my love to the kids and he gave me another hug and hurried his squeaky shopping cart toward the register.
Trey, on the other hand, remained coolly on dry land when I confronted him with Keith’s info that night.
“I skipped the last one,” he said. “You remember.”
He said it like a fact, that I remembered. Not imploring me to remember.
When I informed him that I remembered no such thing, he said, “I told you, I was playing hooky, told Keith I had a cold. I can’t stand the new guy he added, one of his coworkers. Such a pompous ass, thinks he knows everything.”
I just looked at my husband. Blankly.
He laughed. “C’mon, Nora! I told you this. I think you need a vacation. You’re overworking or something. It’s not like you to drop stuff so often.”
“I’m not crazy,” I said, feeling almost crazy as I said it.
“I’m not saying you’re crazy, hon. Maybe just stressed. And where’s your proof I didn’t tell you about my trivia skip-night? You can’t go around accusing people without proof.”
Who am I? Who have I become?
A more decisive (however unwelcome) shift occurred while I was comforting a friend whose fiancé had been unfaithful. Carrie had discovered the infidelity when she answered an incoming call on his phone (one he asked her to pick up since his hands were kneading pizza dough). While she was giving a delivery driver directions to their condo, a text rolled in from someone saved in his phone as “Verizon Customer Service”: Miss you tons, love you more XOXO
Carrie tearfully confronted her fiancé, and eventually he admitted to the affair. But what got me was how much she berated herself for not realizing something was wrong sooner. How he’d been different around her, just slightly different, and when she asked him about it, he swore it was her imagination. The stress of the upcoming wedding was doing things to her mind. And if she was interpreting him as not being all-in with getting married, maybe that was because she wasn’t committed to the relationship.
It was like the building fell on me. And when I dug my way out of the rubble, I knew that when I was sitting with Carrie, it was like I was looking in a mirror.
That night I grabbed Trey’s phone off his nightstand charger while he was reading to the kids. With trembling hands, I punched in the passcode we shared for as long as we had phones, our wedding anniversary. It took me a second to realize that that didn’t unlock the phone. I tried again. And again.
He had changed his passcode.
The queasiness from the other day came back a hundred times more intensely. I could hear his voice rise playfully from the kids’ room as he adopted a storybook character’s persona. I could hear the kids giggle. I could hear my own pulse drumming in my ears.
Clutching the phone in my hand so fiercely I felt muscle spasms up my arm, I stormed into the kids’ bedroom, interrupting the joyful bedtime ritual. “I need to talk to you,” I said to Trey through clenched teeth.
His eyebrows shot up. “Can it wait?”
“Not really, no.”
The children protested the rushed end to storytime, and just for a split second, I wondered who I had become. But that self-questioning moment had passed and I just wanted out of this misery and wanted to learn the definitive truth about something.
“Nora, what is going on with you?” he said when he was back in our bedroom, after having closed the door gingerly. “You scared the kids.”
I flung his phone at him. He ducked away and it hit the floor.
“What are you hiding? You changed the passcode!”
He stooped to retrieve it, and as he was straightening up, he said (in the kind of tone someone might use with a skittish dog), “Can you blame me? Look how unhinged you’re behaving.”
“Don’t try to turn this around on me!” I yelled.
“Are you determined to upset the kids?” he whispered.
“Trey, why would you change your code?”
He sat on the edge of the bed, took a deep breath, looked at me with a kind of pity that made me want to kick something. “The more important question is, why were you snooping?”
“I wasn’t snooping, I was—”
“Trying to unlock my phone.” He knit his brow and shook his head. “Nora, you’ve been acting so weird lately, I don’t know what’s going on for you. But I have to protect myself, and I listened to a podcast about how couples are made up of individuals, and after all, we each have a right to privacy, so I thought it just made sense to have my own space.” He smoothed the bedspread near where he sat. “And see? I was right.”
I hated that a part of me felt like he was making sense. I hated that a part of me felt ashamed for wearing my mistrust like a gaudy hat. I hated that I felt like I had crossed a line I couldn’t uncross.
And most of all, I hated that I still felt like he was hiding, hiding, hiding.
“Trey, this is the way Carrie said Jonah was behaving before she found—”
“Ah!” He stood up abruptly, smacked the heel of his palm against his forehead. “Yes! Jonah is a guy, and he cheated on Carrie, so that means that all guys cheat. You got me, I’m guilty by association!”
“This isn’t a joke!” I said.
“You’re right,” he said somberly. “Nothing about you borrowing Carrie’s life and punishing me with it is funny.” He left the room and slept on the couch that night.
Now, there’s no denying it
Fast-forward to the day all my suspicions (vague and otherwise) were confirmed. The day that changed everything.
At first I thought the strange car pulling into the driveway was someone who’d gone in the wrong direction and needed to turn around. But when the driver got out and approached me where I stood in my open garage, leaning into the car and stowing my stuff for the day, I couldn’t pretend I could predict anything anymore.
She got to the point quickly. I won’t try to recall her exact words because my brain keeps blotting them out. The words aren’t the point. It’s the reality the words delivered that devastated me.
I wanted her to have found the wrong house, the wrong wife, the wrong galaxy. When she drew her phone from her purse and showed me pictures of Trey with her, texts between her and my husband, it was clear this was not a case of mistaken identity. I wanted to disappear, my humiliation was so severe. I had to work to stay upright. I don’t think I’ve ever felt so small. So mortified. At least the kids were already at school. One small mercy.
I called in sick to work. (And it wasn’t a lie: I felt physically sick and would for days. Something had been ruptured in me, and the fallout wasn’t only mental and emotional, but physical too.) Sobbing, hyperventilating, I called my sister. She was at the house in fifteen minutes. With her beside me, squeezing my hand, I called Trey. “You lied,” I blurted and collapsed into weeping again. “You betrayed me.”
He attempted some form of twisting reality, said something like Whatever you think happened, you don’t really know what happened. But when I told him I had pictures, screenshots of texts, when I told him I had met her, he stopped trying to insist my imagination was inaccurately filling in gaps. He was back home within the hour.
There was a period shortly after that truly horrible day where Trey seemed genuinely remorseful. He begged me to let him prove his love to me. He said keeping our family together meant everything to him. He swore the affair was over (that much was confirmed by his affair partner, ironically). He swore he’d never cheated before (I had no way of knowing whether that was true, though he did seem sincere). He agreed to couples counseling.
One of the most difficult, complicated aspects of the recovery process was the recognition that I needed Trey’s support to heal, but my trust in him had been so shattered that I couldn’t even fathom how I could lean on him in that way. I carried this longing with me. A longing for the safety of home in Trey, and a deep fear of Trey as the source of the danger. . .an instinct to flee from him. It felt impossible to reconcile these contrary needs.
But for awhile, he tried his best. He reverted his phone’s passcode to the one we had shared. He let me see his texts anytime I wanted. He turned on location sharing so I could see where he was at all times. And most importantly to me and my pain, he invited me to ask questions about the infidelity, to break down in tears when I needed to (without him getting defensive or pulling away), to ask “How could you do this to us?” time after time without showing impatience.
I’m not sure when the gaslighting started creeping back in, but I know it was after we both committed to trying to heal the relationship. Maybe within a couple of months of the discovery. And I can only see it clearly as gaslighting now, looking back after more than a year has passed.
“Nora, shouldn’t you be looking to the future by now? Who is it helping, asking me to rehash details about the past?”
I started getting responses like those, and even though they were often delivered in a calm tone of voice, they only made me feel worse. There were times I wondered if something was broken in me, if another betrayed spouse would be further along the road to recovery, would be able to “let the past go already.” But then I’d hear an inner voice say: He violated your trust, this isn’t about how you’re handling it!
There were days that Trey acknowledged that. But there were other days when he seemed annoyed by me wanting to see his phone, and on those days he’d mumble some version of: “It’s not fair to blame me for your childhood stuff. For your dad abusing your mom. I’m not him. Maybe you haven’t worked through your old toxic relationship patterns after all.”
On those days, I cried in the bathroom—face pressed against a bath towel—more often than I stood up to him for shifting the blame to me.
Still, with the help of my own therapist, I found my voice. . .rather than dismissing it before I even spoke.
Trey dodged my questions about whether the affair had started earlier than he’d admitted. I had clues that he’d been cheating while we were on a family vacation, a major one that we’d planned for years. He dodged my questions by questioning me.
“Didn’t you have a great time on that trip?” he asked. “You said it was the best vacation you’d ever had. Didn’t we make memories? All those pics with the kids? Those weren’t real? How could I have been cheating when you said you felt so close to me?”
“Trey, you’re being defensive.”
“I am not being defensive. Any guy who’s being accused like this would stand up for himself this way.”
“So you’re saying I don’t deserve to know the truth?”
“Not at all. I’m saying that you’ve got the truth. You’re being unreasonable.”
“That whole vacation,” I said, “where I thought we were good togeth—”
“Don’t you dare revise family history with your hangups and insecurity, Nora. Those memories of that trip are so special to me. I won’t let you tarnish them.”
“Wait, so you’re the victim now?”
“Honey,” he said, with a warmth I knew and loved, a warmth that almost convinced me to overlook the content of his words. “I’m working to rebuild trust, doing everything you and our counselor asked. But if you never trust me, how can I ever prove myself? You’re setting me up to fail. Setting us up to fail. Let’s move on, okay?”
Finally, reuniting with myself
I wish I could say untangling myself from the web of gaslighting was easy, that it was just a matter of cutting the right thread and I was free. I wish.
In reality, it was a gradual, often frustrating process. It wasn’t exactly linear, but rather, it involved advancements and retreats. Progress and temporary regression. And what I see now was that my healing had to start with me.
I needed to learn to trust myself again first. To fully believe that I was worthy of that trust, and understanding why my trust in Trey (and, because of the gaslighting, trust in myself) had been so deeply shaken. My husband’s behavior and responses to my questions created an atmosphere of confusion and uncertainty; the anxiety and hypervigilance that resulted was a normal human reaction to the fog of shifting explanations and the attempt to blame me for my confusion—none of that was because of some inherent failing in me.
After Trey committed to individual counseling alongside our couples infidelity recovery therapy, he did the work to take responsibility not only for the unfaithfulness, but for the gaslighting he perpetuated during and after the affair. With the shell game of gaslighting out of the way, I gradually began to see the man I fell in love with more and more, and was able to experience the reasons I said yes to his proposal all those years ago. I was able to come back to the life we built, the family we have, and feel it as a source of safety once more. A space where my instincts are valid, where I don’t dismiss internal questions for fear they’ll upset Trey, where trust is something I give and receive. . .with just cause.
Don’t get me wrong, we’re not perfect, not as a couple and not as individuals. But we weren’t perfect before Trey’s infidelity, either, and that’s fine by me. We’re still a work-in-progress, and I feel my husband’s earnest intention to do the work to help me heal from the massive betrayal he caused me and the marriage.
_________
*Although the pain of infidelity (and gaslighting) are very real, Nora and Trey are entirely fictitious and have been created solely to illustrate the incredibly difficult (and common) experience of the wayward partner gaslighting the betrayed partner, along with some of the ways in which gaslighting can manifest. If you are a betrayed partner being emotionally manipulated by your partner, I hope you find this narrative-style article helpful. And I hope that knowing that you are not alone in this uniquely painful situation brings you comfort.
_________
Rich Nicastro, PhD, is a licensed clinical psychologist with three decades of experience working with individuals and couples. His work is informed by psychodynamic and attachment theory, trauma theory, and parts-oriented approaches to psychotherapy. Dr. Nicastro provides teletherapy to clients in participating PSYPACT states.
Interested in working with Dr. Nicastro?
To inquire about therapy or schedule an initial consultation, email Rich@RichardNicastro.com






