Among the many painful facets of the fallout from infidelity trauma is an experience that can be hard to put into words, perhaps because it tends to feel so confusing and unnerving. And that is some variation on this question:

What is real?

For many betrayed partners shocked and devastated by the revelation that the person they trusted above all others has cheated, they haven’t only lost trust in their partner, they’ve lost trust in themselves. That shattering of self-trust is a deeply disorienting upheaval since it results in a questioning of everything, with no obvious answers.

Was his love ever genuine?

Was she lying to me when she said she never felt this way about anyone else?

Were they just going through the motions with me or were they ever happy and fulfilled?

Losing trust in your partner, losing trust in yourself

The value of trust as the foundation for a longterm relationship cannot be overstated. For an intimate relationship to succeed, each partner needs to feel emotionally safe enough to be vulnerable. And that foundational vulnerability is not possible without trust. 

Infidelity shatters the bedrock of trust. (It is of course possible to rebuild trust, through hard work, commitment, perseverance, and knowledge; but for this article we will focus on the phase of affair recovery prior to the reestablishment of trust.) 

What’s not so obvious on the surface is that shattered trust doesn’t only manifest as the betrayed partner losing trust in the wayward partner. It also often includes the betrayed partner losing trust in themselves. This is incredibly painful, and can leave you feeling like you have no one to turn to when you’re trying to find your center and plant your feet on solid ground. 

A betrayed wife loses trust in herself as well as her husband

Nora and Jermaine had been married for sixteen years when she learned about his longterm affair. She discovered the infidelity while they were on vacation. He had inadvertently left his phone by the hotel pool and staff returned it to the room while he was in the shower. 

“I’ve never scrolled through his phone before, my trust in him was so unwavering,” Nora said. “But for some reason, on that day, I felt compelled to open it. I found an avalanche of texts, including one he’d sent that morning where he told her he couldn’t wait for the vacation to finally be over so he could see her again.”

The shock of learning that your life partner has betrayed you is one of the most devastating, most profound shocks anyone can endure. It can be so overwhelming that it obliterates any kind of thinking in the immediate, so that all you experience is pain and confusion. But when the shock abates and you regain the power of linear thought, the sudden trust vacuum will likely be starkly apparent. And not just the loss of trust in your partner who cheated.  

“I have always thought of myself as a good judge of character,” Nora said. “But I guess I was kidding myself. I mean, I thought he was having the time of his life on our shared vacation. He said as much! And yet he was longing to get back to his affair partner.” She sighed deeply and shook her head in disbelief and resignation. “How can I ever trust myself again?”   

The victim of the infidelity can begin to harshly question their own judgment in choosing this person as a life partner in the first place; in believing the lies that the wayward partner told in order to conceal the affair; in failing to identify “red flags” in their partner’s behavior; in assuming their marriage/relationship was healthy while, unbeknownst to them, their partner was cheating.

What is real? And what was real?

How betrayal trauma shatters the past 

There is a concept known as “afterwardsness” that is relevant here. Introduced by Freud, afterwardsness describes the grueling emotional second-guessing that occurs after a significant trauma. It causes the individual to revisit the past, even happy memories, and see them in a new light, with the knowledge of the current trauma overlaid. 

You can see how afterwardsness can tarnish what’s come before as it’s replayed in the traumatized mind. At the root of this is the question of what is real, what can be relied upon, what can be fully trusted.

Humans are wired to control as much as possible in one’s life and environment. And yet, we can agree that there is a great deal—if not most—of life that we cannot control. Part of what makes longterm, committed relationships so appealing is the sense of security they create in the midst of life’s overall uncertainty. “It’s the two of us against the world,” you may hear a couple say. There is a powerful feeling of certainty in that sentiment. What’s implied is that no matter what happens “out there,” the marriage/relationship will be the safe place to weather life’s storms.

When one partner violates the agreement to remain faithful, the relationship suddenly becomes a fraught, emotionally dangerous place for the betrayed partner, and the certainty of a shared safe space is disrupted (sometimes temporarily, sometimes for good). Because the human mind is vigilant for danger (it’s quite literally in our wiring), and because the mind can’t do anything about undoing a betrayal that’s already occurred, it revisits and analyzes everything (in Nora’s words: “I feel like I’m stuck in an endless post-mortem”). As painful as this is, it can feel preferable to feeling helpless, and truly, we are helpless when it comes to changing the past. 

So in the mind’s imperative to be sure a betrayal of trust never happens again, it turns over (and over and over) all that has come before, even the good times, and holds them up to a mistrusting light. Ultimately, what is left is: 

What is real? What was real? I can’t tell!  

Healing from infidelity: Learning to trust yourself again

Afterwardsness is one of the many ways the mind experiences trauma, but it doesn’t have to be the place where you stay forever. As trust is slowly rebuilt, and as connections are reestablished (the connection with your partner and/or the connection with yourself), afterwardsness starts to give way to a more balanced vision of the past. That recalibrated experience of what’s come before allows the betrayed partner to decipher and hold onto aspects of the relationship and their partner that were genuinely real and meaningful. This is a common occurrence for couples who find a pathway to healing. 

“The whole thing has been awful, just awful,” Nora said. “And if I’m honest with myself, I can say that what’s even worse than worrying I won’t be able to trust Jermaine ever again is that I worry I can’t trust myself ever again. I don’t know what to do with that, where to go from here.”

Reestablishing trust is never easy, nor is it a quick one-and-done process. Whether or not you can find your way back to trusting your partner, and whether or not your marriage/relationship survives the infidelity, it will be crucial to regain trust in yourself, to once again rely on your own instincts and perceptions. An important step toward learning to trust yourself again will be to realize (and internalize) that you couldn’t have known about or prevented your partner’s infidelity. 

The wayward partner often goes to great lengths to deceive the betrayed partner, and to think you could have somehow seen through the deception is unrealistic. The infidelity did not occur because of something you failed to notice. . .the affair happened due to a series of choices made by the wayward partner.

It’s early days for Nora and Jermaine in their affair recovery journey, so it’s not yet known whether their marriage will survive. “I know we’re both working at it,” she said, “but right now, I can’t trust that his efforts are genuine.” 

She paused thoughtfully before continuing. “One thing I know for sure: I don’t feel okay not trusting myself, so for me, that’s the priority. Getting back to the place where I rely on my own inner voice rather than questioning it in every moment.” 

[Note: Nora and Jermaine are a fictitious couple used to explore issues that are real and common for many couples in the affair recovery process.]

~~~

Rich Nicastro, PhD, is a clinical psychologist with over 25 years of experience supporting individuals and couples as they navigate betrayal trauma and other emotional challenges. He offers teletherapy to clients throughout the United States. To work with Dr. Nicastro and join his waiting list, please email him at Rich@RichardNicastro.com.

Infidelity Trauma: The Loss of Self-Trust